After realizing that I'd never read any Shakespeare I decided to embark upon the Shakespeare Newbie project, a reading of all the plays from A-Z. I've read 11 so far. Here are my rankings.
1. Tempest 2. Hamlet 3. Antony and Cleopatra 4. Titus Andronicus 5. Cymbeline 6. Coriolanus 7. Henry IV, Part I 8. Henry IV, Part II 9. As You Like It 10. All's Well That Ends Well 11. The Comedy of Errors